Page 1 of 1

Is nutrient BROTH safe to use?

Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2011 1:58 pm
by bob800
Hello,

I am just getting started in amateur biology. I've been reading your safety page (https://www.sciencebuddies.org/science- ... Agar.shtml) on the different types of agar, and I've found it very helpful. However, for some experiments where the growth media must be a liquid, I will need to use nutrient broth, which is the same as the nutrient agar, but without the agar to gel it. Is this also a safe growth medium for home experiments? Also, I was wondering if it would be fairly safe to prepare this at home using a pressure cooker at 15 PSI to sterilize? The preparation comes from an Amateur Scientist article:
"Stir a pound of freshly ground hamburger into a liter of distilled water and put it in the icebox (at about 40 degrees F.) for 10 hours. Then skim off the fat which rises to the top and filter the remaining liquor through a single thickness of clean muslin. Add distilled water to bring the liquor back to a full liter, then add five grams of peptone and five grams of ordinary table salt and stir until the salt is dissolved. Pour 50 milliliters into a second flask and set it aside [this is what I would be using] . Then add 15 grams of agar to the 950-milliliter portion.

"Bacteria, like other organisms, are sensitive to the acid-base balance of the medium in which they grow. Those grown in this experiment prefer a neutral medium. The two solutions just prepared will be slightly acid; they must accordingly be adjusted to neutrality (pH 7) by adding precisely enough sodium hydroxide to counteract the acid. Mix 10 grams of sodium hydroxide in a liter of distilled water. Test the beef broth with a piece of blue litmus paper. An acid broth will turn the blue paper red. The sodium-hydroxide solution will turn red litmus blue. Add a drop or two of sodium hydroxide to the liquor, stir, and with the glass rod put a drop of the solution on a piece of blue litmus. The paper in contact with the drop will probably turn pink. Add more sodium hydroxide to the liquor and test again. Continue this until the test drop causes no change in the color of either red or blue litmus.

"Each container of liquor is then heated almost to 212 degrees F. for half an hour. This will precipitate the proteins in the liquor. The proteins are removed by passing the hot liquor through coarse filter paper. Each filtrate is again brought up to volume by adding distilled water

"One hundred milliliters of the hot agar medium are poured into each of six Erlenmeyer flasks, which are then stoppered with wads of absorbent cotton. Five milliliters of the liquor containing no agar are poured into each of 10 test tubes, which are similarly stoppered.

"The media are now sterilized. The containers may be placed in boiling water for half an hour on each of three successive days. They may alternatively be sterilized in a pressure cooker. Put the containers inside the cooker, add two inches of water and pressure-cook for 20 minutes. Be sure to cool the cooker slowly. Rushing the job by quenching the cooker with cold water will cause the internal pressure to drop suddenly and the vessels of hot medium to boil over. Stoppered tubes of tap water and other solutions may be sterilized by either of these methods.
Or would it be significantly safer to buy dehydrated medium?

Any help would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!

Re: Is nutrient BROTH safe to use?

Posted: Sun Jul 24, 2011 9:22 am
by donnahardy2
Hi,

It is definitely safe to prepare nutrient broth at home. Reading the recipe, you can see that nutrient broth contains proteins, salt, water, and enough sodium hydroxide to make a neutral pH solution.. And since it is cooked after preparation, it is sterile. It makes a very good food for bacteria to grow in. There’s nothing hazardous about the medium itself.

However, either homemade or purchased nutrient broth can support the growth of a wide variety of bacteria. If you are planning to grow bacteria from a source that contains unknown organisms, it is always possible to grow something that is potentially pathogenic. Since bacteria can grow to 10,000,000 bacteria per milliliter, you should always take precautions when handling samples growing in broth or liquid. You should avoid culturing samples from hazardous sources such as sewage effluents or raw chicken. What are you planning to do with the nutrient broth?

The Science Buddies website has excellent information on working with microorganisms safely.

https://www.sciencebuddies.org/science- ... fety.shtml

Please let us know if you need any other help with your project. Microbiology projects are always great. What question are you trying to answer with your project?

Donna Hardy

Re: Is nutrient BROTH safe to use?

Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2011 9:50 am
by bob800
Thank you for your response!

I'm trying to see if I can collect microorganisms from the soil which produce antibiotics, which is an idea I got from another Amateur Scientist article (which I can post if necessary). Basically, several soil samples are collected from various areas and cultured in petri dishes containing different growth media (I was only going to use nutrient agar, since other types can selectively grow pathogens, according to https://www.sciencebuddies.org/science- ... Agar.shtml). Once a colony of bacteria has grown in the incubator (which I would construct out of wood and a few small light-bulbs), they are then sub-cultured in nutrient broth. This is necessary because small paper disks must be soaked in the cultured broth to collect the possible antibiotics. Anyway, once the disks have been soaked, they are then transferred to a petri dish containing test bacteria (in this case, Sarcina lueta was used). Finally, there should be a zone of inhibition around the paper disks containing antibiotics.

The most dangerous-looking step seems to be the sub-culturing. As long as I take precautions to dis-infect my work area regularly, wear latex gloves, do the entire procedure in the basement (away from food), use non-selective growth media, and of course wash my hands thoroughly, would this be reasonably safe to do at home, as long as common sense is used? Of course, all equipment would be dis-infected with bleach after the experiment.

Re: Is nutrient BROTH safe to use?

Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2011 10:31 am
by donnahardy2
Hi,

Soil samples contain primarily bacteria that make their living decomposing organic materials and recycling elements, so would be safe enough for you to work with at home with the precautions you have described. Be sure and keep the Petri dishes and broth cultures away from young children and pets. And, bleach is perfect for disinfecting the samples at the end of the experiment.

This project you are doing is challenging and very interesting. I’m sure you will have some original results to report for your science project.

Here is a Science Buddies project on this topic that may include some additional background information that will be helpful.

https://www.sciencebuddies.org/science- ... p014.shtml

One important point in setting up antibiotic resistance assays that many beginning researchers miss is that the age of the test culture is very important. For optimum and consistent results, you should grow your test strain up overnight and use this young culture to spread on the agar plate before you add the “antibiotic” discs. Be sure to test all of your samples in two experiments to demonstrate reproducibility of your results.

I would be interested in hearing about your results when they are available. Do let me know if you have any questions in the meantime.

Donna Hardy

Re: Is nutrient BROTH safe to use?

Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2011 11:31 am
by bob800
Thanks for the tip about using the bacteria right away. According to another Amateur Scientist article:
Purchased cultures can be perpetuated indefinitely by keeping them in beef broth at room temperature and inoculating a fresh tube of medium (by putting a drop of the old culture into it) every other day. If the culture can be stored at 40 degrees F., the growth of the bacteria is slowed and new media need be inoculated only once every six days.
Can these"revived" cultures be used as well? I would assume that they could be treated as "young" cultures; what do you think?

I will definitely post my results when I get them. It will be awhile before all my materials arrive, though.

Thanks again,

bob800

Re: Is nutrient BROTH safe to use?

Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2011 1:42 pm
by donnahardy2
Hi,

Here is information from the Science Buddies website for storing bacterial strains. If you transfer your culture every 7-10 days, it will probably remain viable. What organism are you going to use for your test strain?

https://www.sciencebuddies.org/science- ... ains.shtml

For your experiment, you can use cultures that have stored for a while, but you will need to transfer them to fresh, warm medium and grow them for a few hours to make sure you are working with young, actively growing cells. Bacteria will double in number every 20 minutes to an hour, depending on the temperature, so it doesn’t take long to grow up a fresh culture.

The following explanation of the bacterial growth curve will help you understand why it is important to use a young culture for antibiotic resistance testing. The growth curve shows the time after inoculation that bacteria are growing and dividing rapidly. Antibiotic resistance testing works most consistently with bacteria that are transferred to the agar plate from log-phase or early stationary phase. Once the bacteria have been in stationary phase for a while, or if they are really old and going into death phase, their metabolism changes and it takes a long time to recover and grow in the test plates. The science fair judges will be very impressed if you pay attention to this important detail in your experimental design.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacterial_growth


Donna Hardy