Which Materials Can Catch a Bubble?
AbstractCan you catch a bubble with your hands? What if you use another material, like a piece of paper or aluminum foil? Try this science project to find out which materials can catch a bubble without popping it.
Find out which materials can catch a bubble without popping it.
Bubbles are fun and beautiful—but they are also fragile! Bubbles are made from a thin film of soapy water with air inside. Many things can cause this film to break, popping the bubble. Bubbles will frequently pop when they come in contact with a solid surface, but they can even pop without touching anything, as the water in them gradually evaporates and the film gets weaker. However, sometimes you might notice that bubbles can land without popping.
Whether a bubble pops when it comes in contact with a solid surface depends on many factors, including the surface properties of the material. You probably know that different materials have different properties, some of which you can see or feel, like color or hardness. However, materials have other properties that are harder to detect directly. Surfaces can be hydrophobic (repel water) or hydrophilic (attract water). You can observe this by dropping water onto it and seeing whether the drops form big beads (hydrophobic) or spread out in thin sheets (hydrophilic). Whether a material is hydrophobic or hydrophilic depends strongly on its surface roughness.
Some materials, like sandpaper, have macroscopic surface features, meaning you can feel the bumps and see them with your naked eye. However, other materials have microscopic surface features. Even if a material looks and feels smooth to you, it might have very tiny bumps or pores. These can actually help the material repel water, because the surface of the water, held together by surface tension, is unable to penetrate the tiny gaps in the material. Other materials, like paper or sponges, have larger gaps that help them absorb water.
All of these properties, along with factors like how fast the bubble is moving and whether the surface is wet, can affect the likelihood that the bubble will pop when it lands.
Terms and Concepts
- Surface tension
- Look at the materials in the room around you. What properties can you see? What properties can you feel?
- Do you think any of the materials will catch a bubble without popping it?
Read all about bubbles on this website from the Exploratorium Museum in San Francisco, developed by Exploratorium scientist Ron Hipschman:
- Hipschman, R., 1995. Bubbles, The Exploratorium Museum, San Francisco, CA. Retrieved June 6, 2007.
This article explains the components of a bubble formula and the history of bubbles:
- Pepling, R., 2003. What's That Stuff? Soap Bubbles, Chemical and Engineering News, Volume 81, Number 17, pp. 34, publication of the American Chemical Society (ACS). Retrieved June 6, 2007.
For help creating graphs, try this website:
- National Center for Education Statistics, (n.d.). Create a Graph. Retrieved June 25, 2020.
Materials and Equipment
- Bubble solution. You can buy some or make your own at home by mixing 1 cup of water with 2 tbsp of dish soap and 1 tbsp of glycerin or light corn syrup.
- Bubble wand and small bowl or other container to hold your bubble solution
- Different horizontal materials/surfaces to test, such as: paper, aluminum foil, wax paper, the floor (wood, tile, carpet, etc.), tables/countertops, etc. You can try any material or surface that you can find around your house—just make sure it is large and flat enough that you can easily blow bubbles onto it.
- Lab notebook
- Prepare a data table like Table 1. Fill in the different materials you will test in the first column.
|Number of bubbles that did NOT pop
- Prepare the different materials you will test (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Example experimental setup.
- Try to blow a single bubble onto your first material. It is OK if you blow more than one bubble, but you will have to keep track of all of them, so try not to blow too many. You can ask a volunteer to watch the bubbles if that helps.
- If the bubble pops as soon as it touches the material, write "popped" in the "Bubble #1" column for that material.
- If the bubble lands on the material without popping right away, write "not popped" in the "Bubble #1" column for that material (even if it pops a few seconds after it lands).
- Repeat step 3 four more times for this material.
- Repeat steps 3–4 for each of your remaining materials.
- For each material, add up the number of bubbles that did not pop. Write this number in the last column of your data table.
- Make a bar graph of your results, with the material name on the x-axis and the number of unpopped bubbles on the y-axis.
- Based on your results, which material was best at catching bubbles? Which material was the worst? How do your results compare to your predictions?
Ask an Expert
- Does the orientation of the surface matter? Try using some tape to put your materials on a wall, or even on the ceiling. Can you still get bubbles to land on them?
- Try different recipes for a homemade bubble solution, as described in this project. Which bubbles are easiest to catch?
If you like this project, you might enjoy exploring these related careers: