Which Acne Medication Can Really Zap That Zit?
|Time Required||Long (2-4 weeks)|
|Material Availability||This science project requires access to some laboratory equipment, such as a 37°C incubator, as well as some specialty reagents, which can be ordered online. See the Materials and Equipment list for more details.|
|Cost||High ($100 - $150)|
|Safety||This science project involves the use of the bacterium E. coli. Standard microbiology and bacterial safety guidelines should be followed, see the Microorganisms Safety Guide for more details. To maintain a sterile environment, you will be working near a lighted Bunsen burner. Keep all flammables, including hair and clothing, away from the flame.|
AbstractHave you ever wondered where acne comes from and how you can treat it? One major cause of acne is the colonization and infection of clogged pores with bacteria. In this science project, you'll test different acne medications and treatments to determine their effectiveness at killing bacteria.
In this science fair project you will determine which over-the-counter acne medications are the most effective at stopping the proliferation of E. coli.
Sandra Slutz, PhD, Science Buddies
Cite This PageGeneral citation information is provided here. Be sure to check the formatting, including capitalization, for the method you are using and update your citation, as needed.
Last edit date: 2018-04-21
Have you ever had acne? Almost everyone has! Clinicians estimate that nearly 100% of the population will have acne at some time during their lives, usually as adolescents. Acne forms in pilosebaceous units, which are compromised of a hair; a follicle, or shaft in the skin through which the hair grows; and a sebaceous gland. The sebaceous gland produces an oily substance, sebum, which protects the skin and hair, making them waterproof and preventing them from drying out. Dead keratinocytes, or skin cells, and excess sebum can clog the pilosebaceous unit. The clogged follicles are ideal environments for the bacteria that normally live benignly on the skin's surface, to proliferate. This proliferation causes local inflammation and the visual signs are referred to as acne.
One way to treat acne is to stop the proliferation of the bacteria. In this science fair project, you will test a variety of over-the-counter acne medications to determine which is the most effective at preventing bacterial proliferation. Although Propionibacterium acnes (P. acnes ) is the bacteria which most frequently contributes to acne, in this science fair project you'll be using the bacterium Escherichia coli (E. coli). E. coli is safer and easier to work with. You'll use the Kirby-Bauer disk-diffusion method to measure the effectiveness of each acne medication. With this technique, bacteria is uniformly spread across an agar plate, then sterile disks, each coated with a compound (in this case, medication) to be tested, are placed on the surface of the agar. The compounds diffuse out from the disk into the agar. The concentration of the compound is highest right next to the disk and gradually reduces as you move out in concentric circles from the disk. If a compound is effective against the bacteria at a certain concentration, no colonies will grow in the area of the plate where that compound is equal to or higher than the effective concentration. The areas without bacterial growth are called zones of inhibition and are characterized by a clear circle around the disk in an otherwise contiguous lawn of bacteria. The larger the zone of inhibition is, as measured by the diameter of the clear circle, the more effective the compound.
Terms and Concepts
- Pilosebaceous unit
- Sebaceous gland
- Propionibacterium acnes (P. acnes)
- Escherichia coli (E. coli)
- Kirby-Bauer disk-diffusion method
- Zone of inhibition
- How does acne develop?
- What are the different types of lesions that make up acne?
- What are the causes of acne?
- Can you name a few types of treatments and medications are available to treat acne?
- What type of bacteria is E. coli? What kind of growth conditions does it require? How about P. acnes?
- What are the real-world applications of the Kirby-Bauer disk-diffusion method?
Here are some resources about acne to get your background research started.
- American Academy of Dermatology. (n.d.). Acne. Retrieved April 20, 2018 from https://www.aad.org/public/diseases/acne-and-rosacea/acne#overview
- National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases. (2006, January). Questions and Answers About Acne. Retrieved April 9, 2008 from http://www.niams.nih.gov/Health_Info/Acne/default.asp
This animation from the CCBC Faculty Web shows the complete procedure and use of the Kirby-Bauer disk-diffusion method in a clinical setting. The bacterial growth conditions are different in this project, but the basic concept is the same. The last section covers how to interpret the results of the test, which will be particularly useful for your science fair project.
- CCBC Faculty Web. Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing by CLSI (NCCLS) Reference Disk Diffusion Method (Kirby-Bauer). Retrieved April 20, 2018, from http://faculty.ccbcmd.edu/courses/bio141/labmanua/lab19/images/kirby%20bauer.htm
This website explains the Kirby-Bauer Disk-Diffusion method.
- Rollins, D.M. and Joseph, S.W. (2000, August). Antibiotic Disk Susceptibilities: Kirby-Bauer Disk-Diffusion Method. Retrieved April 17, 2008 from http://www.life.umd.edu/classroom/bsci424/LabMaterialsMethods/AntibioticDisk.htm
News Feed on This Topic
Materials and Equipment
Note: If you are carrying out this experiment in a school laboratory, which is recommended, some of the materials and equipment listed may be more readily accessible.These items can be purchased from Carolina Biological Supply Company, a Science Buddies Approved Supplier:
Nutrient agar plates. The number of plates you need depends on how many medications you choose to test. See the table for details.
# of Medications to be Tested # of Plates Needed 3 6 4–6 9 7–9 12
- E. coli, K-12 strain
- Bacterial spreader. Alternatively, sterile cotton swabs may be used (from a previously unopened package counts as sterile).
- Sterile transfer pipettes. Alternatively, a micropipette (P1000) and sterile tips may be used.
- 70% ethanol. Note: If you are ordering this chemical through Carolina Biological Supply Company, the chemical must be ordered by a teacher and shipped to a school or business address, so plan accordingly.
- Sterile petri dishes (one for each medication being tested). Alternatively, another type of small sterile dish may be used.
- Sterile disks
You will also need to gather these items:
- Permanent marker
- Bunsen burner
- Acne medications (minimum of 3 different medications)
Sterile forceps or tweezers
- To ensure that they are sterile, autoclave them. If autoclaving is not an option, place them in boiling water for 15 minutes.
- Water should be autoclaved to sterilize it. If autoclaving is not an option, boil the water for 15 minutes. Alternatively, distilled water, from a new, unopened bottle, may be used.
- Sterile cotton balls (from a previously unopened package counts as sterile)
- Note: If you have access to one, it is recommended that you use a 37°C incubator to grow your plates in – but the project can be done without one, see Experimental Procedure for more details.
- Ruler with millimeter (mm) markings
- Lab notebook
Disclaimer: Science Buddies participates in affiliate programs with Home Science Tools, Amazon.com, Carolina Biological, and Jameco Electronics. Proceeds from the affiliate programs help support Science Buddies, a 501(c)(3) public charity, and keep our resources free for everyone. Our top priority is student learning. If you have any comments (positive or negative) related to purchases you've made for science projects from recommendations on our site, please let us know. Write to us at email@example.com.
Which Acne Medication Can Really Zap That Zit?
For health and safety reasons, science fairs regulate what kinds of biological materials can be used in science fair projects. You should check with your science fair's Scientific Review Committee before starting this experiment to make sure your science fair project complies with all local rules. Many science fairs follow Intel® International Science and Engineering Fair (ISEF) regulations. For more information, visit these Science Buddies pages: Projects Involving Potentially Hazardous Biological Agents and Scientific Review Committee. You can also visit the webpage ISEF Rules & Guidelines directly.
This science fair project involves the use of the bacteria E. coli. While E. coli is not considered a biohazardous or dangerous bacteria, it is important to always properly clean and dispose of bacteria and supplies that come in contact with it. See the Bacterial Safety guidelines below for more details on how to handle bacterial cleanup and waste.
Preparing Plates for Acne Medication Effectiveness Test
Label your nutrient agar plates.
- Petri dishes should always be labeled in permanent marker and on the bottom of the plate. Labeling the lid is not sufficient as the lid is removable and might accidentally get swapped with another plate.
- Three of the plates are controls to make sure your bacterial lawns grow well and evenly. Label these plates: Control #1, Control #2, and Control #3.
The other plates are your actual acne medication trial plates. Divide each plate into four equally sized quadrants with the permanent marker. See Figure 3 for an example.
- Label one quadrant on each plate Water. This will be your negative control.
- The other three quadrants should be labeled with the names of three different acne medications you are testing.
Each acne medication will be tested three times, but it should be tested on three different plates so that the maximum amount of experimental error is accounted for in your observations. Do not put all three replicates of an acne medication on the same plate.
So, for every three acne medications you will label three plates where the quadrants read:
- Water, Acne medication 1A, Acne medication 2A, Acne medication 3A
- Water, Acne medication 1B, Acne medication 2B, Acne medication 3B
- Water, Acne medication 1C, Acne medication 2C, Acne medication 3C
Figure 3. This photo shows how your agar plates should be divided into quadrants and labeled.
To make your bacterial lawns, you will need to work in a sterile environment. Work next to a lighted Bunsen burner, but be careful around the flame! If you have long hair, tie it back. Do not wear flowing sleeves, and avoid reaching across the flame.
Take out your E. coli culture and gently shake it to evenly distribute the bacteria in the liquid. Using a sterile transfer pipette or micropipette, add 500 μl of the E. coli culture to the surface of an agar plate. Try to put the culture in the center of the plate.
- Tip: One drop is about 50 μl, so 500 μl is equal to approximately 10 drops.
- Sterilize your bacterial spreader by dipping it in a beaker containing approximately 30 mL of 70% ethanol, and then holding the spreader in the flame of the Bunsen burner for 10 seconds. Caution: You do not want the beaker of ethanol to catch on fire; ethanol is highly flammable, which is why it is used here in combination with the flame to sterilize the spreader. To avoid potential accidents, keep the beaker of ethanol on the opposite side of your workspace from the Bunsen burner.
- Hold the spreader away from the flame for an additional 30 seconds to let it cool. If the metal is too hot when it touches the bacterial cells, it will kill them.
Using the spreader, spread the drops of E. coli culture uniformly around the agar plate.
- Start by gently touching the spreader to an area of the plate far away from the drops of bacteria. This way, if the spreader is too hot, you won't kill the bacteria.
- Move the spreader to the center of the plate where the bacteria are. Spread the bacteria across the whole surface of the plate using up-and-down motions.
- Turn the plate 90 degrees and repeat the spreading motion.
- Keep turning the plate by 90 degrees and spreading until you have been around the whole plate (a total of four 90-degree turns).
- Remember to put the lid on the agar plate as soon as you are done to prevent other bacteria and contaminants from floating in.
- Repeat the pipetting, sterilization, and bacterial spreading steps for all of your agar plates.
- Note: If you do not have a bacterial spreader use sterile cotton swabs (from a new, unopened box) to spread the bacteria across the surface of the agar plates. You may need to add more of the E. coli culture if the swabs are soaking up too much of it.
- Take out your E. coli culture and gently shake it to evenly distribute the bacteria in the liquid. Using a sterile transfer pipette or micropipette, add 500 μl of the E. coli culture to the surface of an agar plate. Try to put the culture in the center of the plate.
- After you have spread all your agar plates, wait 5 minutes for the surface of the plates to dry. Remember, keep those plates covered!
Now you are ready to apply the negative control (sterile water) and medications to the agar plates.
- Do not add any substances to the three control plates.
The remaining plates will each get a negative control – a disk dipped in sterile water – and up to three disks dipped in different acne medications.
- Put each of your acne medications into its own sterile petri dish.
- Using sterile forceps, dip a sterile disk into the first acne medication you want to test. If the medication is a liquid, gently shake the disk to remove excess liquid. If the medication is a cream or gel, use a sterile cotton swab to remove excess medication from the disk.
- Make sure that the label on the underside of the plate matches the medication you are testing. Place the disk in the middle of the appropriate quadrant on one of the agar plates. See Figure 4 for an example. Using the forceps, press down gently to ensure good contact between the agar plate and the disk.
- Clean and re-sterilize the forceps between each use (i.e. after you have placed one disk, but before you place the next disk) by wiping the forceps with a sterile cotton ball that has been wet with 70% ethanol.
- Repeat Step 4b so that you have three plates for each acne medication.
- Using the same technique, dip a disk in the sterile water. Apply one disk of sterile water to each agar plate. This will serve as a negative control. Sterile water should not create zones of inhibition; if zones do appear, you have a cross-contamination problem.
Figure 4. The experimental plates should look similar to this once you have applied the medicated disks to the agar.
Incubate the plates at 37°C for 48 hours. Make sure to invert the plates (lid-side down, agar-side up) so that any water condensation does not fall onto your bacterial lawn.
- Note:If you do not have access to a 37°C incubator you can grow the bacteria at room temperature. Keep the plates away from direct sunlight, but in a warm part of the house. For example, you may want to keep them in a plastic bag (to protect them from dust) next to a heating vent or the clothes dryer. The incubation time will be longer than in an incubator. Start checking your control plates after 72-96 hours of growing time.
Measuring Zones of Inhibition
After 48 hours of incubation (72-96 hours if you are not using a 37°C incubator), examine your plates (keep the lids on while you do this).
- Do you see a lawn of bacteria on the three control plates you made? If not, incubate the plates for an additional 24-48 hours until there is a decent bacterial lawn.
- The three control plates should show relatively uniform lawns. If you see dense bacterial growth in some areas and swatches of light or no bacterial growth in other areas, then your bacteria-spreading technique needs improvement. You will need to repeat the experiment again, paying special attention to spreading the E. coli culture across the plates to get reliable data.
If the medications you chose are effective at preventing E. coli growth, you should see zones of inhibition around the medication disks. The clear zones around each disk should be circular with a relatively uniform diameter since diffusion of the substances through the agar is the same in every direction. If the zones of inhibition do not have uniform diameters, there are two possible problems:
- The medication was not distributed evenly across the disk.
- There was poor contact between the disk and the agar.
- If the variability is particularly high, you might want to repeat the experiment, paying careful attention to how you apply the acne medications.
- There should be no zone of inhibition around your sterile water controls.
- Using a ruler, measure, in millimeters (mm), the diameter of the zone of inhibition around each medication disk. Do not take the lids off to do this. Instead, invert the plates and measure with the agar side closest to you. Record all your data in a data table in your lab notebook. You will have three measurements for each medication, each from a different plate.
- Analyze your data. Are the sizes of the zones of inhibition consistent across your replicates? Calculate the average and standard deviation for the medications you tested. Which acne medication was most effective; which was least effective?
- If you cross-compare the active ingredients in each medication with the results of your experiment, do you see any trends? Are there certain ingredients that seem to contribute significantly to preventing E. coli growth? If so, consider designing an additional experiment to test your new hypothesis.
Bacteria are all around us in our daily lives and the vast majority of them are not harmful. However, for maximum safety, all bacterial cultures should always be treated as potential hazards. This means that proper handling, cleanup, and disposal are necessary. Below are a few important safety reminders. You can also see the Microorganisms Safety Guide for more details. Additionally, many science fairs follow ISEF Rules & Guidelines, which have specific guidelines on how bacteria and other microorganisms should be handled and disposed of.
- Keep your nose and mouth away from tubes, pipettes, or other tools that come in contact with bacterial cultures, in order to avoid ingesting or inhaling any bacteria.
- Make sure to wash your hands thoroughly after handling bacteria.
- Proper Disposal of Bacterial Cultures
- Bacterial cultures, plates, and disposables that are used to manipulate the bacteria should be soaked in a 10% bleach solution (1 part bleach to 9 parts water) for 1–2 hours.
- Use caution when handling the bleach, as it can ruin your clothes if spilled, and any disinfectant can be harmful if splashed in your eyes.
- After bleach treatment is completed, these items can be placed in your normal household garbage.
- Cleaning Your Work Area
- At the end of your experiment, use a disinfectant, such as 70% ethanol, a 10% bleach solution, or a commercial antibacterial kitchen/bath cleaning solution, to thoroughly clean any surfaces you have used.
- Be aware of the possible hazards of disinfectants and use them carefully.
If you like this project, you might enjoy exploring these related careers:
MicrobiologistMicroorganisms (bacteria, viruses, algae, and fungi) are the most common life-forms on Earth. They help us digest nutrients; make foods like yogurt, bread, and olives; and create antibiotics. Some microbes also cause diseases. Microbiologists study the growth, structure, development, and general characteristics of microorganisms to promote health, industry, and a basic understanding of cellular functions. Read more
PharmacistPharmacists are the medication experts. They advise doctors, nurses, and patients on the correct drug dosage for a patient's weight, age, health, and gender; on interactions between drugs; on side effects; on drug alternatives; on costs; and on ways to give drugs. They also dispense drugs at pharmacies, according to prescriptions, checking for dangerous drug interactions, and educating patients on how to take drugs, what reactions to watch out for, and how long it should take for drugs to work. Read more
Medical & Clinical Laboratory TechnicianDoctors need information to decide if a person is healthy or sick, if a baby's earache is bacterial or viral, or if the man next door needs medication to lower his cholesterol and prevent a heart attack. The information often comes in the form of results from lab tests. Medical and clinical laboratory technicians are the people who perform these routine medical laboratory tests, giving the doctors the information needed to diagnose, treat, and prevent disease. Read more
- The science fair project above does not distinguish between bacteriocidal and bacteriostatic compounds. Those that are bacteriocidal kill the bacteria, whereas those that are bacteriostatic temporarily inhibit bacterial growth. Devise an experiment to test whether the acne medications are bacteriocidal or bacteriostatic. You should only test the medications which proved effective against E. coli (i.e. those with the largest zones of inhibition).
- Do any of the zones of inhibition have one or a few colonies within an otherwise bacterial-growth-free area? If so, think about what could be different about these colonies. Design an experiment to test your hypothesis.
- Which antibiotics is E. coli susceptible to? Design an experiment to find out. Note: Antibiotic sensitivity disks are available from online suppliers such as Sargent-Welch and Carolina Biological.
Ask an ExpertThe Ask an Expert Forum is intended to be a place where students can go to find answers to science questions that they have been unable to find using other resources. If you have specific questions about your science fair project or science fair, our team of volunteer scientists can help. Our Experts won't do the work for you, but they will make suggestions, offer guidance, and help you troubleshoot.
Ask an Expert
News Feed on This Topic
Looking for more science fun?
Try one of our science activities for quick, anytime science explorations. The perfect thing to liven up a rainy day, school vacation, or moment of boredom.Find an Activity