Baseball Bat Debate: What's Better, Wood or Aluminum?
|Time Required||Very Short (≤ 1 day)|
|Material Availability||Readily available|
|Cost||Low ($20 - $50)|
|Safety||Minor injury possible|
AbstractSo baseball's your game? Well, slugger, science and math abound in baseball. Just look at the zillions of "stats." In this project, you can produce some interesting baseball statistics of your own and perhaps settle a long-standing debate. You'll set up experiments at your local playing field to find out which type of bat is better, wood or aluminum. Play ball, and batter up!
The goal of this project is to compare the hitting power and "sweet spots" of wood versus aluminum baseball bats.
Darlene Jenkins, Ph.D.
The idea for this project came from this DragonflyTV podcast:
- Twin Cities Public Television. (n.d.). Baseball by Reed and Nick. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=go4wOQn8Zk8.
Cite This PageGeneral citation information is provided here. Be sure to check the formatting, including capitalization, for the method you are using and update your citation, as needed.
Last edit date: 2018-03-23
Baseball may be the all-American game, but it's not without its controversy. Players and fans alike hotly debate massive volumes of statistics and data. They compare and discuss players' batting averages, runs batted in, and slugging percentage, along with pitchers' allowed hits and runs, strikeouts, and innings pitched. They argue over the importance of ball park locations, weather, altitude, and left-handed pitchers. One of baseball's long-standing disputes revolves around the question of which type of bat, wood or aluminum, is better for whacking a long one out of the park.
In this project, you'll take the scientific approach to answer this question. You'll set up an experiment to measure and compare the average hitting distances of a wood and an aluminum bat. You'll also investigate how each type of bat affects the "feel" of a hit, and whether that has any correlation to how far the ball flies after it leaves the bat.
To get you started, check out the video showing what two young baseball players, Reed and Nick, learned at their ball park when they compared Reed's wooden bat to Nick's aluminum bat in a side-by-side batting experiment. Read on to see how you can set up your own tests using your favorite bats at a ball park near you. Once you have gathered data and evaluated your own personal "stats", you can reach a scientific conclusion to settle the bat controversy for yourself.
Several factors come into play when comparing wood bats to aluminum bats. Aluminum bats are hollow, except near the handle end, so they tend to be lighter and swing faster than a solid wood bat of the same length. The aluminum also tends to "give" a little more than a wood bat when it comes in contact with the ball. This contributes to the different "feel" of a hit between the two types of bats. The greater elasticity of an aluminum bat also means there is a slight "trampoline effect" from its surface so that the ball rebounds differently than it does after it leaves the more rigid surface of a wood bat. Each of these characteristics has been carefully studied by bat manufacturers and baseball physics researchers. In this project, you'll read about or investigate how differences in bat composition, balance, feel, and swing can contribute to the speed and travel distance of a batted ball.
Most seasoned ball players associate solid, long hits with connecting with the ball right on a bat's so-called "sweet spot." Scientific studies have shown that several such points exist near the wide end of the bat. Their exact locations vary with the type of bat, how the bat is held, and the criteria used to define the spot. There are separate and sometimes overlapping sweet spots associated with longer hits, decreased bat vibration, and less bat movement in the hands of a batter after a hit. For these reasons, some scientists now prefer to describe a general region between four and seven inches from the end of the bat as a "sweet zone" rather than use the term "sweet spot." They define the sweet zone as the area of a bat that produces the most powerful hit with the least amount of "sting" or discomfort to the batter. In your experiments, you will mark the "sweet zone" on the end of each of your bats and see if hits from this region actually produce the longest line drives and feel the best to the batter.
What causes a bat to "bite back" or sting a batter's hands during one hit and not during another? Again, there's been interesting research into the physics of bats, balls, and the energetic outcome that results when the bat and ball each rebound after impact. Basically, it's a matter of vibration and location. In general, the bat tends to vibrate more along its length if the ball hits it outside the sweet zone on the bat. The vibrations continue to reverberate along the bat's length down through the handle—and sometimes painfully—to the batter's hands and arms. Bat vibrations can also mean less energy is transferred back into the ball after a hit explaining, at least in part, why the ball travels less when a batter has a hit that stings.
To come up with equally good explanations for the results from your batting experiments, first gather some background on the science of bats, balls, hits, and swings. A list of search terms and questions is included in the next section as a guide.
Now do your research, gather up your gear, then head out to the park to let those line drives fly. Batter up, and may the best bat win!
Terms and Concepts
To do this project, you should do research that enables you to understand the following terms and concepts:
- Physics of baseball
- Baseball bat-ball collisions
- Sweet spot of a baseball bat
- Sting from a bat
- What factors contribute to a long hit in baseball?
- What and where are the multiple "sweet spots" on a baseball bat?
- What causes a "sting" sensation when you hit a baseball?
- How are aluminum bats different from wood bats in how they interact with a baseball?
- Which type of bat hits a baseball farther?
- Introductory website into the history and science of baseball, sweet spots, swings, and more:
Spadaccini, J., Fowler, J., et al, (1998). Science of Baseball. Exploratorium. Retrieved June 22, 2007, from http://www.exploratorium.edu/baseball/index.html.
- Everything you ever wanted to know about the physics of baseball from a scientist who studies it:
Russell, D. (n.d.). The Physics and Acoustics of Baseball and Softball Bats. The Pennsylvania State University. Retrieved March 14, 2018, from http://www.acs.psu.edu/drussell/bats.html.
- Twin Cities Public Television. (n.d.). DragonflyTV Kids Do Science - Baseball. Retrieved January 12, 2018, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=go4wOQn8Zk8.
News Feed on This Topic
Materials and Equipment
To do this experiment you will need the following materials and equipment:
- Playing field
- Baseball bats: one wood, another aluminum of equal length
- Baseballs: at least three of the exact same size and type
- Baseball tee
- Long tape measure or electronic measuring device (if not metric, then convert feet to meters)
- Stakes or colored flags to mark where baseballs land
- Powered chalk
- Blue painter's tape (3/4" wide)
- Notebook or paper
- Pen or pencil
- One "slugger" to hit the balls
- One outfield assistant
Baseball Bat Debate: What's Better, Wood or Aluminum?
- Arrange with your assistant the day and time to meet at the ball park.
- Prepare two "Record of Hits" data tables similar to the example below. Use one to record the data from the wood bat and the other to record the data from the aluminum bat.
- The goal is to collect data from at least 30 good hits from each bat, ideally including at least 10 hits from above the sweet zone, 10 hits from within, and 10 hits from below the sweet zone. You should alternate between the wood and aluminum bats every five hits. Line drives down the middle are best, but you can include hits off to either side as long as they are not foul balls.
- Wrap two pieces of tape around the bat to mark the outer margins of the sweet zone on each bat (an area between 4–7 inches from the end).
- Set up the baseball tee at home plate, and take a few practice swings to warm up.
- When you are ready to start collecting data, roll the baseball in powdered chalk before each hit so you'll be able to tell where the ball connects with the bat. Right after each hit, record whether the ball hit above, within, or below the sweet zone on the bat.
- Following each hit, also note the "feel" of the hit by rating the amount of vibration or "sting" felt. Use a simple numerical system, i.e. 0 = no discomfort or vibration; 1 = very low; 2 = low; 3 = medium; 4 = medium high; 5 = very high level of discomfort.
- For each hit, the out-field assistant should mark where the ball lands with a stake or flag. Measure and record the distance in meters of each hit before the batter takes the next swing off the tee.
- Some hints to keep your data consistent:
- The same person should hit all balls.
- Don't do 30 hits in a row with one type of bat. Alternating between the wood and aluminum bats after every five hits gives a fairer comparison, especially when fatigue could be a factor toward the end of the experiment.
- If the batter starts getting tired, he/she should rest a few minutes between switching bats.
- If getting at least 30 good hits, especially line drives down the middle or 10 hits in each of the three areas of the bat, is too challenging for one day, you can split the experiment between two or more days, but the weather conditions should be similar.
- The more hits you have from each area of the bat, the better your statistics will be when analyzing your data. So, 30 total good hits is a minimum; 60 total hits or more would be even better.
|Record of Hits|
|Type of Bat:||Date:|
|"Sweet Zone" Location|
|...cont. to 29|
Analyzing Your Data
- Total the distances of the hits for those above, within, and below the sweet zone for each bat. Calculate the average hit distances (in meters) for each category.
- Prepare a bar chart of the data for the three sweet zone categories showing the average hit distance from the wood bat and aluminum bat next to each other.
- What are the differences in average hitting distance between the two bats? Is one bat consistently better than the other for the three sweet zone categories?
- How much difference in distance is there between hits that were in the sweet zone and hits that were out of (above and below) the sweet zone?
- Total the numbers of the "sting" rating for the hits above, within, and below the sweet zone of each bat. Calculate an average "sting" rating for each bat in each three sweet zone categories.
- Prepare a second bar chart of this data showing the average sting rating of the wood and aluminum bats side by side for each of the sweet zone categories.
- Are there any differences in the average sting ratings between the three sweet zone categories? Do the ratings correlate to what you would expect for hits in and out of the sweet zone?
- Looking back at your original Record of Hits data table, how many of the hits that felt good (had a low rating on "sting" level) were associated with a long distance? How many of the hits that stung were associated with a long distance?
- On the other hand, how many of the hits that felt good (had a low rating on the "sting" level) were associated with short distance? How many of the hits that stung were associated with a short distance?
- Do you see any consistencies with the "feel" of a hit and the distance the ball traveled?
- For help with data analysis and setting up tables, see Data Analysis & Graphs.
- For a guide on how to summarize your results and write conclusions based on your data, see Conclusions.
If you like this project, you might enjoy exploring these related careers:
StatisticianStatisticians use the power of math and probability theory to answer questions that affect the lives of millions of people. They tell educators which teaching method works best, tell policy-makers what levels of pesticides are acceptable in fresh fruit, tell doctors which treatment works best, and tell builders which type of paint is the most durable. They are employed in virtually every type of industry imaginable, from engineering, manufacturing, and medicine to animal science, food production, transportation, and education. Everybody needs a statistician! Read more
Commercial & Industrial DesignerHave you always loved art? Do you have a good eye for beauty, balance, and form? How would you like to see your designs show up in toy stores? Or in a sporting goods store? Or at a car dealer? Commercial and industrial designers create the shape and form of every type of manufactured good that you can think of—from toys, sporting goods, and medical equipment to high technology products, furniture, toothbrushes, and toasters. They design the form of new products that are as beautiful and pleasing to look at as they are functional. Read more
- More hits: Do you think collecting more data would produce different (or more convincing) results? Repeat your experiment several days in a row and re-evaluate your data. Recruit one or two additional batters to participate in the experiment to see if your results are the same for all hitters or more specific to an individual's batting technique.
- Different bats: Try using wood and aluminum bats of different lengths and weights. Are your results consistent for all sizes of bats? Research the importance, if any, of bat length and weight to the distance a ball travels after being hit. Is your data consistent with these findings?
- Size of batter: Would increasing or decreasing the muscle mass behind the swing have any effect on how far a baseball travels? Repeat the experiment with another batter, or two, who are very different in height and weight from you. Research the physics of muscle power and swing to better interpret and explain your results.
- Type of ball: Does the type of baseball make a difference to distance or feel of a hit? Use a hard ball and softball in a repeat of this experiment. Investigate what scientists who study baseball physics say about the differences between hits with a hard ball versus hits with a softball.
- Narrow down the "sweet zone:" From your research, identify the more precise locations of two specific sweet spots: the COP (center of percussion) and the sweet spot associated with decreased bat vibrations. Mark each spot on your bats, and use these smaller points in a repeat experiment to evaluate how each may play a role in the distance the baseball travels after a hit. For easy instructions on how to locate these sweet spots on a bat, see two Exploratorium activities: Finding the Sweet Spot and Minimizing Handle Forces.
- To learn more about solid wood versus corked bats and how the weight of a bat and the speed of a swing affect the distance a baseball travels, check out another Science Buddies project, The Physics of Cheating in Baseball.
Ask an ExpertThe Ask an Expert Forum is intended to be a place where students can go to find answers to science questions that they have been unable to find using other resources. If you have specific questions about your science fair project or science fair, our team of volunteer scientists can help. Our Experts won't do the work for you, but they will make suggestions, offer guidance, and help you troubleshoot.
Ask an Expert
News Feed on This Topic
Looking for more science fun?
Try one of our science activities for quick, anytime science explorations. The perfect thing to liven up a rainy day, school vacation, or moment of boredom.Find an Activity