Hi, I am conducting this experiement of measuring sugar content with a a laser pointer. I have done all the steps that the website says and am using sciencebuddies.org equipment as well. I have measured all index of refraction for all liquids with %10, %20, and %30 sugar concentration as shown in the table. However, I am stuck in the step that asks me to use the index of refraction to measure the sugar content. I don't know how to get from the index of refraction to the percentage of sugar concentration of an unknown liquid. Please help me as I have been trying to figure this out for a very long time and my project is due in less than a week.
Thank you, I really appreciate your help
Gustavo
Trouble measuring sugar content, please help!
Moderators: kgudger, bfinio, MadelineB, Moderators
-
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 5:35 pm
- Occupation: Student 11th Grade
- Project Question: I am conducting the project from your website "Measuring Sugar Content with a Laser." I know how to measure the index of refraction with the given amounts of sugar, but what I do not understand is how do I calculate the sugar concentration of an unknown liquid just based on the index of refraction. I have already done all experiments that the project asks me to do, but I am stuck in getting a real number for the sugar content of an unknown solution. Please Help
- Project Due Date: Wednesday November 29, 2012
- Project Status: I am conducting my experiment
-
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 5:35 pm
- Occupation: Student 11th Grade
- Project Question: I am conducting the project from your website "Measuring Sugar Content with a Laser." I know how to measure the index of refraction with the given amounts of sugar, but what I do not understand is how do I calculate the sugar concentration of an unknown liquid just based on the index of refraction. I have already done all experiments that the project asks me to do, but I am stuck in getting a real number for the sugar content of an unknown solution. Please Help
- Project Due Date: Wednesday November 29, 2012
- Project Status: I am conducting my experiment
Re: Trouble measuring sugar content, please help!
The project is due in two days, any suggestions can help. Thanks
-
- Former Expert
- Posts: 338
- Joined: Sun Jul 10, 2011 5:48 pm
- Occupation: retired physicist
- Project Question: n/a
- Project Due Date: n/a
- Project Status: Not applicable
Re: Trouble measuring sugar content, please help!
Hello gus1996,
I just reviewed the project at https://www.sciencebuddies.org/science- ... ml#summary.
I think you are expected to "interpolate" the sugar content from the results of your experiments on known-concentration solutions. You can do this using a very common technique called "linear interpolation." What that means is that you assume the index of refraction varies linearly (along a straight line) between your measured values.
Here's an example. Suppose you measure n(10%) = 1.3479 and n(20%) = 1.3639. Then you measure the index of refraction of an unknown solution and get n(unknown) = 1.3575.
1.3575 is at 60% of the distance between 1.3479 and 1.3639. The concentration of the unknown solution is then 60% of the distance between 10% sugar and 20% sugar, or 16% sugar.
Hope this helps, WW
I just reviewed the project at https://www.sciencebuddies.org/science- ... ml#summary.
I think you are expected to "interpolate" the sugar content from the results of your experiments on known-concentration solutions. You can do this using a very common technique called "linear interpolation." What that means is that you assume the index of refraction varies linearly (along a straight line) between your measured values.
Here's an example. Suppose you measure n(10%) = 1.3479 and n(20%) = 1.3639. Then you measure the index of refraction of an unknown solution and get n(unknown) = 1.3575.
1.3575 is at 60% of the distance between 1.3479 and 1.3639. The concentration of the unknown solution is then 60% of the distance between 10% sugar and 20% sugar, or 16% sugar.
Hope this helps, WW
-
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 5:35 pm
- Occupation: Student 11th Grade
- Project Question: I am conducting the project from your website "Measuring Sugar Content with a Laser." I know how to measure the index of refraction with the given amounts of sugar, but what I do not understand is how do I calculate the sugar concentration of an unknown liquid just based on the index of refraction. I have already done all experiments that the project asks me to do, but I am stuck in getting a real number for the sugar content of an unknown solution. Please Help
- Project Due Date: Wednesday November 29, 2012
- Project Status: I am conducting my experiment
Re: Trouble measuring sugar content, please help!
Thank you so much, I found a formula on excel that interpolated the values for me. You really helped!
Thanks
Thanks
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2012 10:32 pm
- Occupation: Student 11th Grade
- Project Question: I would like to base my project on AstroPhysics, I have thought about looking at Cosmology/Cosmic Inflation, but I really have no idea where to go with it, especially since I live where there aren't any labratories, can you help come up with ideas?
- Project Due Date: My Regional Science Fair will be sometime in March, but I am planning on attending National Science Fair for a second year which is in May; I have lots of time but lots to do.
- Project Status: I am just starting
Re: Trouble measuring sugar content, please help!
i have already done this whole project, the trick is not to measure the length of diverted beam and use sin, but to measure length x and L and use tan.
when measuring the content of sugar you have to go 0g 5g 10g etc of sugar and then 100g 95g 90g with water. I used an electronic gram scale and just pored everything into a small container on the gram scale and normally you would subtract the weight of the container but mine had a feature that did it on it's own.
and yes when measuring unknown sources you would go by what info you already have, but a quicker way is:
since you already have the measurements on the wall across from the laser you can say, "ok, I know 5% is here and 10% is here, my beam is aproxiamatly inbetween the 2 and so I will make it 7.5%
when measuring the content of sugar you have to go 0g 5g 10g etc of sugar and then 100g 95g 90g with water. I used an electronic gram scale and just pored everything into a small container on the gram scale and normally you would subtract the weight of the container but mine had a feature that did it on it's own.
and yes when measuring unknown sources you would go by what info you already have, but a quicker way is:
since you already have the measurements on the wall across from the laser you can say, "ok, I know 5% is here and 10% is here, my beam is aproxiamatly inbetween the 2 and so I will make it 7.5%